Today I found myself thinking about that time I got a ticket for driving with an expired tag. Not just a few weeks expired. Not even a couple of months expired. Nope. A full 15 months expired. Fifteen. Months. I somehow managed to miss not one, but two renewal cycles. And yet there I was, blithely driving around completely unaware of my vehicular delinquency.
When I got the ticket, I was in complete disbelief. This wasn’t me. I’m a responsible person. I pay my bills. I show up on time. I keep track of my obligations. And yet, here I was, face to face with an expensive ticket informing me that I was actually failing as an adult.

If you’re anything like me—a generally conscientious, put-together adult—then you know how disproportionately rattling these small mistakes can feel. They don’t feel small. They feel huge. They feel like cracks in the image we try so hard to maintain: responsible citizen, competent adult, reliable friend, professional leader. And when that image takes a hit, it can set off a cascade of emotional drama that is far bigger than the actual infraction.
How You Automatically Respond to a Mistake
Let’s break it down, shall we? Because whether it’s an expired tag, a missed deadline, a forgotten birthday, or a financial misstep, you may notice having a few different responses. And how you respond is related to the “story” you learned and created about who you are. This story results in an automatic response that is often self-defeating or can even increase discord with others. I will break down some of these auto-responses and how they became your go-to pattern.
Option #1: Denial
In response to a big mistake, you pretend it didn’t happen. You ignore it and procrastinate the cleanup. The brain goes into this self-protective mode of shock and disbelief. Because if we’re “responsible people,” then mistakes like this don’t happen. This can be caused if your family of origin had a pattern of sweeping things under the rug. Things don’t get talked about.
This probably affected you deeply. Think of a time when one of your parents made a mistake that caused hurt or distress, only to then move on like nothing happened. Your feelings were implicitly invalidated. You repeat this pattern through denial and do not give attention or validation to the damage caused to yourself or your loved ones. In short, you invalidate yourself or those you hurt.
Option #2: Excuses or Blaming Others
Next, we scramble for explanations. “Well, I never got the notice.” “You didn’t tell me what you wanted.” And you know what? Some of these excuses may even be partially true. But underneath the rationalizations is a quiet (and sometimes not-so-quiet) desperation to protect our self-image. Because if we can explain it away, maybe it means we’re not actually flawed. The result is often blaming others.
How did this happen? It’s possible that you learned this from a parent with narcissistic traits, mimicking the behavior of never taking responsibility for actions. Or, you were the golden child and your parent or parents always made excuses for you. In other words, you were never truly challenged to take accountability. Deep down there is a self-belief that “if I let others see that I was a failure, they will not love me.” With that belief running your life, you turn to excuses and blame to protect yourself from the perceived fear of loss of status or respect. Ironically, being someone who always blames others is a guaranteed way to lose respect.
Option #3: Deep Shame
You shut down, feeling overwhelmed with negative thoughts about yourself, calling yourself names and thinking about how stupid and useless you are. Then you start with the fears: “How could I be so careless?” “What will my family think?” “What if the person I’m dating sees this and decides I’m actually terrible at adulting?”
When we turn a simple mistake into a referendum on our entire character, it is likely due to a family history of highly critical and shaming statements. When you were a child, you were learning about the world and probably making mistakes all the time. That’s how we learn. If your parents treated these mistakes with unrelenting criticism or abusive comments, you likely internalized those messages as defining who you are and how stupid or unworthy you are when you make a mistake.
The Myth of Perfect
Perfectionism loves to masquerade as high standards, but in reality, it’s an unattainable, moving target. If your goal is to never mess up, you will live in constant anxiety and disappointment because perfection is, by definition, impossible. Even the most responsible people screw up. In fact, it’s often the most responsible people who feel these mistakes the most deeply because they’ve built so much of their identity around being the one who doesn’t screw up.
Part of the reason these “small” mistakes feel so significant is because they threaten our internal narrative. If you’ve always seen yourself as the organized one, the competent one, or the one who holds it all together, then a simple oversight doesn’t just represent a missed to-do list item—it feels like a betrayal of your core identity.
But here’s the truth: Identity isn’t binary. You’re not either perfectly responsible or completely irresponsible. You’re a full-spectrum human being. You can be 99% responsible and still miss an expired tag. You can be a deeply caring friend and forget a birthday. You can be financially prudent and still overdraft your account one month. One mistake does not define you.
So What Do You Do When You Screw Up?

Here’s where we get to the good stuff. Because while making mistakes is inevitable, how we respond to them makes all the difference. Here are the steps I recommend, both as someone who’s been there and as a therapist who helps people navigate these very moments:
1. Pause and Reflect
First, take a breath. Really. A deep one. Our knee-jerk reaction is often to catastrophize or scramble for excuses. Instead, sit with the reality of the situation. Acknowledge the facts without judgment.
“Yes, my tag was expired for 15 months. That is objectively true.”
Notice that this statement doesn’t include any moral evaluation. It’s not “I’m so irresponsible” or “I’m a failure.” It’s simply what happened.
2. Challenge Your Inner Critic
That nasty voice in your head that says you’re a failure? It’s wrong. Start talking back to it with evidence. This is how you separate the facts and circumstances from the added-on self-criticism:
“I usually pay my bills on time.”
“I show up for my family.”
“I’m dependable at work.”
“I manage a lot of responsibilities well.”
The one mistake doesn’t erase all of that. You are a responsible person who made a single oversight. Period.
3. Normalize Human Error
We live in a world of endless demands: work, family, friendships, finances, health, home maintenance, social obligations, civic duties—the list goes on. Of course something’s going to fall through the cracks every now and then. If anything, missing a detail like a tag renewal might just reflect that you’ve been prioritizing more important things.
4. Extract the Lesson
Perfectionism offers no growth, but mistakes are fertile ground for learning. Ask yourself:
“Is there a system I can put in place to avoid this in the future?”
“Can I give myself permission to delegate or ask for reminders?”
“What does this tell me about my bandwidth and where I need support?”
Instead of stewing in shame, get curious. Curiosity opens the door to self-compassion and problem-solving.
5. Let It Go
Finally, forgive yourself. Fully. Completely. The ticket is paid. The tag is renewed. The world keeps turning. Holding onto the shame doesn’t serve you, and it certainly doesn’t make you more responsible in the future. If anything, it just drains your emotional resources.
The Real Goal: Progress, Not Perfection
As a therapist, I see so many clients who hold themselves to impossible standards. They’re afraid to make mistakes because they believe those mistakes reveal something fundamentally flawed about them. But what I remind them—and myself—is that being a fully functioning adult isn’t about flawless execution. It’s about resilience. It’s about how quickly you recover, how kindly you speak to yourself, and how much grace you extend to your very human self.
So the next time you screw up (and you will, because you’re human), remember this:
- Your worth is not defined by your mistakes.
- Responsible people make mistakes, too.
- The goal isn’t perfection. It’s learning, growth, and self-compassion.
In fact, I would argue that your ability to navigate mistakes with grace and humor is one of the strongest markers of true maturity.
And if you need a therapist to heal the deeper childhood wounds that created all those self-defeating automatic responses, reach out. You deserve healing and a new relationship with your mistakes.